Season 1, Episode 6 – Get to Know Your AMC

In this episode of ValuNation, co-hosts Charlie Johnson and Michael Schwartz pull back the curtain on appraisal management companies (AMCs)—what they do, how they operate, and why so many people in the mortgage and real estate industries misunderstand their role.

If you've ever assumed AMCs are just middlemen or roadblocks, this episode challenges that idea and walks through the real functions, responsibilities, and pressures AMCs face every day.

🎧 Listen to the episode: Episode 6 on RSS
📍 Key topics: what an AMC does, appraisal process, managing risk, client communication, AMCs vs. appraisers

So... What Does an AMC Actually Do?

Charlie and Michael break it down simply: AMCs are not just go-betweens. Their job is to facilitate, manage, and protect the valuation process. That includes:

• Assigning appraisals based on proximity, experience, and availability
• Communicating with lenders and appraisers
• Performing quality control reviews
• Managing deadlines, escalations, and reassignments
• Ensuring compliance with regulations like Dodd-Frank and AIR

“We’re not just pushing paper,” Charlie says. “We’re protecting the process.”

AMCs Walk a Tightrope

One of the big challenges the hosts highlight is how AMCs have to balance two competing priorities:

• Serving their lender clients quickly and efficiently
• Defending the independence and integrity of the appraiser’s work

Lenders want fast turn times and clean reports. Appraisers want flexibility and fair fees. AMCs are stuck in the middle trying to keep both sides happy without violating regulations.

“We get pulled in every direction,” Michael adds. “But at the end of the day, we’re here to support both parties.”

Why Appraisers Get Frustrated

The episode also touches on the frequent tension between AMCs and appraisers. A lot of that comes down to communication—or the lack of it.

Appraisers often don’t get feedback when a report is rejected or flagged, which makes it feel like AMCs are just arbitrarily picky. Charlie and Michael argue that transparency and education are the cure.

“When we explain the why behind our decisions, it goes a long way,” Charlie explains.

Educating the Industry

The hosts also make it clear that most lenders and borrowers don’t really understand the appraisal process. They talk about the importance of educating clients on what delays actually come from—borrower scheduling, property access, incomplete orders—not just blaming the AMC or appraiser.

“We want to be the ones who say, ‘Here’s what’s actually happening,’” Michael says. “That builds trust.”

TL;DR – Episode 6 Takeaways

• AMCs aren’t just middlemen—they’re operational, compliance, and client support hubs
• They balance competing priorities between speed and accuracy
• Communication breakdowns are a major source of frustration
• Education—for clients, appraisers, and even lenders—is critical
• The best AMCs don’t just manage—they advocate, explain, and protect the process

📌 Want a Better Relationship with Your AMC?

Start by asking questions, giving feedback, and remembering that the AMC isn’t working against you—they’re working with constraints most people never see.

👉 Listen to all episodes: rss.com/podcasts/valunation
📸 Follow us: @valunationpodcast on Instagram

‍