What makes a comp legit?
- Proximity.
- Urban: stay within ½ mile.
- Suburban/rural: up to 1 mile, but the closer the better.
- Recency.
- Use sales closed in the last 6 months—prices rose ≈ 3.8 % year-over-year, so stale data will short-change value.
- Parable features.
- Match finished square footage, bed-bath count, and lot size.
- Adjust for upgrades (e.g., your subject’s 200 sf original kitchen ≠ a comp’s brand-new chef’s layout).
Big-picture takeaways
- Buyers / agents – Tight comps help you avoid overpaying in fast-moving markets.
- Mortgage pros – Lenders will scrutinize every sale; cross-check with MLS, Redfin, Zillow before the report goes out.
- Everyone – Six-month filter + same specs = a valuation that stands up to underwriters (and sellers).
Quick script for your next deal
- “Are all three comps within a half-mile and < 6 months old?”
- “What were the key adjustments for kitchen, bath, or lot size?”
- “Let’s pull an MLS sheet to confirm closing dates and concessions.”
🔗 Episode audio: ValuVault – How to Spot Accurate Comps
📚 Learn more: https://nationwideamc.com/